SIDI On Road & Alpinestars Scout Boots – First Impression
Comments (0) Recently, I’ve been interested in replacing my short Alpinestars Ridge boots with more substantial full-length ones. My requirements were that the boots: a) be protective b) be waterproof c) have a lug sole d) be walkable. After much searching, I settled on checking out the SIDI (www.sidisport.com) On Road boots ($325) and the Alpinestars (www.alpinestars.com) Scout boots ($279). Both boots offer good protection over the shins, excellent construction, a comfortable footbed, and a completely waterproof/breathable interior. The On Road presents a cleaner, more attractive look, which fits well with wanting footwear that would be acceptable for a short walk around the city. However, the Scout offers slightly more protection and a flexible clasp-based enclosure. Those two factors, combined with a lower price-tag and better usability, makes the Scout a better deal from my perspective. I feel that one can’t go wrong in choosing either pair of boots, but each targets a different kind of rider. Here is a quick break-down of my observations.
SIDI On Road Boots
1. The SIDI On Road uses 3 Velcro panels for attachment. The bottom 2 panels can be adjusted slightly wider through a second loop.
2. The On Road features hard protection around the heel, toes, and inner ankle. The shin section is simply leather with no added armor.
3. The On Road works better with pants going over the boots instead of inside. Tucking pants inside proved very difficult.
Alpinestars Scout Boots
1. The Alpinestars Scout has a Velcro panel at the top and 3 adjustable clasps. The clasps feel sturdy once in place, and they open/close with firm application of force.
2. The Scout’s lug sole is prone to picking up small pebbles while walking due to the tight tread pattern.
3. The Scout features hard protection around the heel, toes, and inner ankle. There is raised padding and semi-rigid protection in the front of the shin.
4. The Scout works great with pants on the outside or tucked in. The adjustable clasps and wider top opening allowed for a better fit.
Themocracy